“A new prince must always harm those over whom he assumes authority, bot with his soldiers and with a thousand other hardships that are entailed in a new conquest” (5).
These words claimed by Niccolò Machiavelli are Machiavelli’s opinion and are not true. Machiavelli says that in order to rule or take over a new territory, the new leader must rule with an iron fist. Although the iron fist maintains control, it not necessary to be a cruel leader in order to govern.
Machiavelli himself contradicts his own point. Machiavelli gives two possible scenarios for a prince after conquering a new area.
“One of the best and most effective policies would be for the new possessor of territories to go there and live… and the citizens will be satisfied because they have easy access to the prince. If they want to be good citizens, they have more reason to love him, and if they do not, they have more reason to fear him.”
Machiavelli says that the new ruler has the option to become a part of the conquering territory and their citizens will be happier by having personal access to the ruler. As long as the prince can keep his people happy, he will maintain rule over this territory. It is not necessary to be cruel to his conquered state.
As long as a leader shows a conquered people a better life, then that leader does not need to be a cruel leader. It is not true that a prince “must always harm those over whom he assumes authority.”
It's true, Machiavelli likes to argue that it is better for a leader to be cruel and instill fear in the people rather than respect, love and devotion; of which I disagree. However, I think it is important to remember that Machiavelli's Prince is someone who will do anything necessary to preserve and unite a great nation (Italy); though it does not justify cruel behavior it does suggest good intent.
ReplyDeleteYeah I didn't like Machiavelli's statement about being a cruel leader. His reasonings for that don't make sense to me either. It seems to me that cruel leaders would be unliked.Unless Machiavelli has a different definition of "cruel" i would say he's wrong.
ReplyDelete